Skip to main content

Sample The Validity and Reliability of Interpretation from Autobiography and Thematic Apperception Test

THE VALIDITY AND RELIABILITY OF INTERPRETATION

FROM AUTOBIOGRAPHY AND THEMATIC APPERCEPTION TEST

Thematic Apperception Test (TAT) is psychological test that uses picture or images to interpret the personality of individual including their feelings and emotion. The interpretation of the subject must be recorded and analyze to identity their reaction. According to Murray and Morgan the authors of the TAT the subject or client is asked to identify a series of pictures and if they do; the traits, attitudes, needs and other feelings can be revealed accordingly. Or in other words it releases their emotions through pictures. They also added that the stimulus response is not just a fantasy but a reality in each life, the Rorschach and Thematic Apperception is correlated with each other and has been often used clinically.

The clients meets the demand they need to release their emotions and they can relate to the picture accordingly that they are able see to the situations in their life, they added that the particular pictures may show the clients resistance, anxiety and other behaviors when they can relate to the pictures. The proper way of using the test is one on one, personal and in a quiet room to eliminate distraction and interpretation.

Same with Rorschach theory of interpretation that uses inkblot and critically evaluated by psychiatrist to test its validity and reliability to the society, the Freudian principles of repression do not believe in the theory of TAT that it is not scientific nor cannot be measured and therefore should not be used in public because of its validity and reliability that is questionable in nature, lacking of resource and essence but merely a fantasies of individual. Some would say the interpretation is too much to be expected and therefore non- concrete and maybe deceiving or lacking in evidence and unreliable, but again this needs experimentation or evidence.

Helen Sargent of Winter Veterans Administration Hospitals in Kansas says that there is no subjective standard of evaluation the pictures are not necessarily an autobiography or part of life of the clients. This proves that it is hard to judge and there is no specification formulation standard of grading system that should include age, sex, nationality, culture etc. all these deficiencies may lead to erroneous interpretation. The large number of studies of psychiatrist and other social practitioner agrees to Helen since the TAT indicator does not include gender, cultural, historical and other issues concerning the client’s life therefore reliability and validity is once again questioned.

Race is the best questions of validity because the original Thematic Apperception Test picture used in 1935 involved purely Caucasian people and it would definitely influence the response of black and white people since they may not confide in its color. However in 2002 the new sets of pictures have already introduced various races and nationality of people to make it more credible in clinical examination approach and somewhat it has improved the set of TAT assessment.

There is also a question in scoring system that there is no normal standard in assessment of scores. Accordingly Murray’s scoring system they agreed that it may take time to interpret the clients and there should be a variable of accounts, for example what would be the determinant is it their gesture or their answer or both? Most importantly what if the cards are not available or what if the pictures are not in relation to the situations that are needed by the patients? How can it be interpreted? All these and more has been the most questioned and perceived unreliable in the study.

As early as 1964 the TAT version has been initially applied in computer versions to evaluate such responses but the response can only be answered with yes or no that may highly delimit its evaluation even more. Computers are delimited in recording the client’s expressions, tonality of voice, eye contact and body gestures of humans and therefore according to their critics are much more uncertain and unreliable in prediction and in observation, highly not recommended for evaluation.

Much has been said about its reliability and effectiveness, TAT has become one of the most controversial and one of the most highly used projective interpretation techniques it is often used by most clinical psychologist of today rather than Rorschach because the truth is, if they have used this technique religiously it has proven many times its worth for an individual to be effective rather than questioned. However this technique is not recommended to be used in group because of diversity and misleading interpretation. (American Psychological Association 2002)

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Sample Research Proposal on Internet Banking Services

REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE Internet banking refers to the utilization of the Internet for performing transactions and payments by accessing a bank's secure website.It also pertains to the application of financial services and markets through the use of electronic communication and computation(Humphrey et al. 2004).The developments can be subdivided into two main areas. The first is the impact of Internet banking on financial services. Most economists perceive that the existence of the Internet and other electronic communication processes has significantly changed many aspects of the banking industry. A majority of the services normally provided by banks can already be provided by other financial entities (Jayaratne et al. 2001). The second main area is the major transformation that occurred on most financial markets. Nowadays, these no longer need to be related with a physical place. In effect, trading systems for foreign exchanges are gradually becoming global. All these change…

Sample Research Proposal on Smoking Among School Children

TITLE/Name of the proposal: Factors affecting smoking among school (9th &12th) grade in Oman: Smoking among school children 9thgrade to 12th grade in the sultanate of Oman 1-INTRODUCTION The age of smoking initiation has dropped over the past four decades. Since behaviors and attitudes adopted in late childhood or early adolescence predicts future smoking, it is important to understand the smoking and other risk-taking behaviors and attitudes of children aged 12 and younger. There supports the idea of early identification and targeting of children at high risk of smoking in middle school, possibly as early as grade seven. 2-AIM OF THE STUDY a- There is a need to amicably evaluate such knowledge, attitude as well as behavior of school children in Oman those in 9th and 12th grade and inform them with regards to the consequences of smoking mostly affecting their health conditions; b- There is utmost goal for describing substantial affective factors associated with the presence of smokin…

Sample Research Proposal on TOURISM INDUSTRY IN ZAMBIA

Chapter 1 – Background to the Study The Zambian economy has historically been based on the copper-mining industry, which is done the Copperbelt. Output of copper had fallen, however, to a low of 228,000tonnes in 1998, continuing a 30-year decline in output due to lack of investment, and more recently, low copper prices and uncertainty over privatization. In 2001, the first full year of a privatized industry, Zambia recorded its first year of increased productivity since 1973. The future of the copper industry in Zambia was thrown into doubt in January 2002, when investors in Zambia's largest copper mine announced their intention to withdraw their investment. Zambia now needs to depend on other tourism activities to help the economy. The main objective of this study is to investigate Zambia's policy on tourism, and explore mechanisms available to promote this industry elsewhere by identifying tourist attraction areas, and instituting lasting policies by the government, which has …